So there they were. Surrounded and beat down, almost completely diminished, yet not quite finished. We were savoring this. After years of repetition; after seeing the formula so many times it became ingrained into our consciousness that actually caused most of our brothers and sisters to succumb to it in acceptance instead of being with us laying in the kicks, grinding into dust all but one – we were having fun. Some were kicking, some were biting, others were dropping Dusty’s, and I even saw a couple people break out there Hugo’s and hugo-whip them in a manner would make the most bellicose Gun Kaya sensei proud. Nobody stopped us; it was time for a change, and invigorated by the notoriety being received with the rise of China, and all armed with our mandate and like english assassins with our final programe for a purpose we likened to having a cure for cancer, we were implementing our dangerous visions with promises to leave no signs of life. We felt righteous, and in truth I still think we proceeded with the best of intentions in mind. We loved fantasy; and they were turning the fantastic into a non-fluid brand, like a broken record playing continuously their foul wishsong. We were tired of walking through the same land with a different name, we were tired of plots being reduced to instances of deus ex machina easily brought on by the snap of a uber wizard’s fingertips or a god’s whim; we were sick of multi-book tomes that recycled themes from their peers and later themselves. We were tired of preprogrammed ingredients given to factory line-like “writers”. I try to remember when I lost it - my own loyalty sworn to the cause - and it was the coming of the fifth sorceress.
…we were handing out cigars – very pleased with ourselves - some choice brands I think from perhaps Viriconium, or was it Ashamoil? The descendant of the wen on the arse were finished – not physically, but detached from ourselves, and we left the only still surviving one, in fact what was the remnant of our childhood nostalgia beaten down — by no small portion motivated by a growing arrogance — in the gutter to die on the corner of mainstream and slush; Then the strangest thing happened… I swear to Peake, the last one had dragged himself up; one that I didn’t recognize and he laughed; and told us to go fuck ourselves, eh — and told me that I would be back.
And I was….
He held nothing back, he was going to write planned 10 book sequence, with not only uber/overpowered characters, but a world full of them, and that doesn’t even include the Gods, which there are a myriad, both new and elder, and everything in between, some seemingly even more affluent and absurd in ability. He was going to have characters with weapons that have the pretentious quality of having names, and unending armies in constant battles that we mockingly call campaigns, and he was going to undertake the most extravagant and later prove to be the most expansive world building effort epic fantasy had ever seen, he was going to have a Elric clone (and even gave him Stormbringer to boot) and he was only going to be one of 100’s of super beings around every corner, he was going to make them fight – continuously, through 1000 page tomes. Those that thought this was Robert Jordan announcing a new series simply died instantly – and with good reasoning – unable to take the thought of more multi-million dollar marketed bullshit. To put the nail in the coffin, and not to be undone, he even told us he was going to make it a semi shared-world, when we all know there hasn’t been a worthwhile shared-world in over 20 years, with the first incarnation of Thieves World. Not only that, the installment written by the other author was actually decent, even though he felt it necessary to offer asinine comments about an author who is much more accomplished (both critically and commercially) at his craft than he is, and has been for 30 years — most likely ever will be — while trying to make flippant remarks about a series he couldn’t even name right in interview. So here it was; everything we had grown to associate with mediocrity: a high magic world, a deity system, constant war and battles by multiple beings with Kryptonian like stature. Mage duels, Dragons, a multi-book sequence of the fat-fantasy variety that was expanded for at least one installment to even be the dreaded shared world, a world that would of course focus around …an Empire….
And I loved it…
Steven Erikson told us all to fuck ourselves, and accomplished something even more admirable (if not grander) than introducing us — with each installment — to new ideas, and with unimagined creativity around every corner. No, there is no Lovecraftian madcap imagination and baroque style of Mieville, and no it isn’t as creatively inventive and assured like a VanderMeer mosaic, nor do the words seem as effortless and seamless in its weave that we come to both expect and marvel from Jeffrey Ford or a Lucius Shepard, and no he doesn’t play with streams of consciousness like Gene Wolfe, and no he isn’t matching the stylistic beauty that a Catherynne M. Valente achieves with each turn of phrase – instead Erikson did something that makes so much sense it’s easy to see why it took so long for U.S. publishing rights to be garnered — instead of making us forsake what we had been reading completely; our legitimate blame overextending to the innocent elements that should have only been directed at the authors haphazardly applying them, turning elements into clichés, then into tired clichés — he gave us what we had been asking for. How crazy of an idea is that? Much like how Matthew Stover proved with Blade of Tyshalle, and Gary Wassner with his ongoing Gem Quest, and Michael Swanwick with his Iron Dragon’s Daugther that not all contemporary books with Elves in it has to be exclusively directed and marketed (even if it is in self-denial without the accompanying proper YA tag that would to any discernible reader seem logical and apt) to children – Erikson has showed me the error of some of my own past broad comments by becoming a blasted exception!
Didn’t I just talk about epic fantasy in my review of Bakker’s The Darkness that comes Before? Yes, but this isn’t about epic fantasy entirely, which isn’t or wasn’t completely dead due to people like Bakker, Kay, Martin, Mckillip, (and Erikson) etc this is about a sub-genre that really is dead. Sword/Sorcery for all intents and purposes has been dead for decades; not in practice but in relevant application. Gone is the legacy of Howard, Leiber, C.L. Moore, L. Sprague de Camp, Burroughs, Karl Edward Wagner, and some examples of Clark Ashton Smith’s work – the only living master practioneer of the craft remaining, being Michael Moorcock. Make no mistake, these are legends who produced work on a level that rivals anyone then or otherwise, and although their legacy may still be most applicable and even far reaching in other forms and authors not practicing sword/sorcery specifically. Thus, the death of Sword/Sorcery served a purpose; as it grew it fueled and evolved into influences that we can see in works by say someone like a Stover, and indeed I believe Erikson, who no doubt is categorized as an epic fantasy author, however, I see a work that was just brimming with the lost legacy and promise of Sword & Sorcery of the past. If you close your eyes it could be Elric who rules Moon’s Spawn, floating above a myriad of Caines, Mousers, Kulls, Conans, Jirils, Fafhrds, Solomon Kanes, John Carters, Sonyas, Dark Agnes de la Feres, Elaks, Harold Sheas, and Bran Mak Morn inhabiting a setting that’s nothing less than a world-building achievement; a world populated with eternal champions. Erikson has taken the gambit, and used the obvious influences from past masters of fantastic fiction that have as of late been chiefly relegated to being listed as influences in at times solid, but for the most part uninspiring efforts, with the limited canvas favored by authors like a David Gemmell or rubbish like Dragonlance, and has made something altogether new and exciting. A world where the mortals stick it to Ascendants and Gods who meddle in their affairs, a world crawling with at burglars, assassins, Ascendants, munitions experts, engineers, historians, seers, Empresses, priests, high mages, squad mages, shape changers, mortals possessed by deities warlords, where there are beings who walk the land that not merely can, but HAVE destroyed civilizations, soul shifters, hammers that stir the slumber of gods, necromancy, demons, a chained god - only this one is not even from this world - an alien god, in a setting where each deity rules his own realm, and a world that has a sword that can imprison the very god who crafted it within in it; a world that has a timely shipping service that it would make Marty Mcfly’s heads spin; and a world where a flying moon fortress full of some brothers that just love to kick the shit out of people, just one of a multitude of races both mortal and not; in the middle of it all, a legendary company of soldiers who just get it done - first in, last out.
You miss enjoying larger than life Sword & Sorcery characters, but fear the element is not possible in today’s fantasy or has died altogether? Or maybe no author is applying what made Sword & Sorcery great in the past in a manner fitting your more evolved tastes? Give Erikson a try and see how even the ideas of legends can be expanded upon into something altogether new but still bears that unmistakable magic that drew us to lands like Newhon, Barsoom, and Cimmeria, as Steven Erikson turns back the clock while taking us a step forward.
I’m loving this series.
Tags: books, book reviews











11 responses so far ↓
1 Banzai Cat // Nov 11, 2005 at 2:37 pm
Shit Jay, I’m currently reading Midnight Tides and was thinking of doing a blog post on it. But then I saw your post and hell, all I thought was I’ll just refer to it. Erikson rules!
P.S. I might have missed it but I presume you’ve read all 6 books already?
2 jaytomio // Nov 11, 2005 at 2:39 pm
Well, I have read the first five ‘Malazan’ books by Erikson - to my knowledge Book 6, ‘The Bonehunters’ doesn’t come out until next year (if it’s out now and I don’t know it, I’m going to have really commit murder!).
I have read ‘Night of Knives’ as well - but it has a god damn scoff on it, so I think I’m going to be hitting Neil up at Clarkesworld for another one soon.
I’m definitely loving this series, it just suprises me it took so long for someone to think something like this may work - it’s one of the ebst series running now, and I sometimes smile when people say ‘Gardens of the Moon’ just introduces too much for them to read - they don’t know the half of it; considering 3/5 of ‘Deadhouse Gates’ is virtually brand new regarding characters and completely new in setting, not to mention the written quality of the work goes up dramaticaly.
Just a damn good, fun series. I mean ‘Deadhouse Gates’, and ‘Memories of Ice’ are about as good as epic fantasy gets IMHO.
3 JP // Nov 11, 2005 at 2:40 pm
Damn, that’s an epic post in itself!
This was pretty much my reaction to the first 4 volumes of the Malazan books - I must confess that my usual Series Fatigue is beginning to set in, now. But Erikosn actually had me locked in to a series for a good long while - which hasn’t really happened with a new fantasy work for a while!
4 jaytomio // Nov 12, 2005 at 2:41 pm
I’m pretty locked in myself, especially since my understanding is that the next book will be the last within the confines of the Malazan Empire.
I think the delay of ‘The Bonehunters’ comes at a good time to let fans step away from a series that been coming out at a fast pace for a few years nows.
5 William Lexner // Nov 13, 2005 at 2:42 pm
Man, I know you hate this…… but I find Malazan unreadable. You and many others scoffed at my scorn of GotM, and told me to read Deadhouse Gates and Memories of Ice……. I’ve tried and tried and tried….. I simply can’t get into them.
I will give one last (agressive) try after I finish with The Thousandfold Thought. I hope I can find in them what you have.
6 tony preda // Feb 9, 2006 at 3:09 pm
read (and must confess, re -read all of them), guess what you need to really appreciate them, as with any sword&sorcery realm, is a very visual imagination…
7 jaytomio // Feb 11, 2006 at 11:47 am
Indeed!
8 Tomio’s Top 100 of the Last 10 Years (11-20) ; The Bodhisattva // Sep 7, 2006 at 1:31 pm
[...] A bit of a surprise choice but shouldn’t be if you read my ode to Erickson, I often debate (okay not often) myself in which i prefer the most in the series, either this or the second book Deadhouse Gates. Ultimately this become my choice as it becomes the book where the patient reader finally gets a bit of a stop in the 1000 mile per hour sprint Erikson begins with the flawed (but one I still enjoyed) Gardens of the Moon, without actually slowing down. We learn more about the nature of the warrens that have fanboy magic-system junkies weak in the knees, we learn more about the nature of pantheon, the power of Quick Ben, and the humanizing (but still alien) of Anomander Rake via talk with Whiskey Jack adds to both characters. [...]
9 // Oct 6, 2006 at 12:06 pm
< ![CDATA[i just found this piece while browsing .. and well , tears - tears i assure you.
for such a magnificent ode on such a magnificent series ,
to see such a cynical and tired heart as yours reaffirm its faith
cheers]]>
10 Reading Roundup - ; The Bodhisattva // May 28, 2007 at 12:32 pm
[...] I finished a complete reread of books last three books and Esselmont’s Night of Knives. I loved the series anyway, but now I have a much more confident grasp on this massive undertaking. I really enjoyed getting [...]
11 Review: Night of Knives by Ian Esslemont « The Bodhisattva // Oct 20, 2007 at 11:03 am
[...] extension of Steven Erikson’s Malazan Book of the Fallen sequence (see my early ode to the series here). The review will probably make little sense to those who aren’t familiar with the series, but I [...]
Leave a Comment